The evolution of digital design has transformed how artists and animators approach dimension in their work. While 2D art remains a beloved traditional medium, 3D art has surged in popularity due to advancements in technology and its versatility in modern media. Both forms have distinct characteristics, advantages, and limitations, making them suitable for different creative needs.
2D
Two-dimensional art operates on a flat plane defined solely by height and length (X and Y axes), relying on layered compositions, strategic shading, and perspective tricks to imply depth where it actually doesn't physically exists. Images can be constructed flatly on single layers or multiple layers to create better distinction of depth and object individuality. None the less, even when you have multiple layers, this are all 2D layers that stack to be 2D. This is due to the fact that 2d layers and shapes do not have any depth no mater how many you stack.
2D drawing can be seen on traditional animation, illustrated media, and indie games. Its mostly prized for its stylistic flexibility and direct handcrafted appeal, evident in works like Studio Ghibli’s hand-painted frames. However, 2D’s limitations become apparent when dynamic camera angles or volumetric realism are required, as every adjustment demands laborious redrawing to captivate the essence and realism of a 3D world.
3D
In contrast, three-dimensional art introduces depth to the already existing model of height and length with width (X, Y and Z-axis) through digital modeling. When you work with 3D shapes you have to keep in mind the dimensions of your object to maintain proportionality of what you want to create as well as angle views.
Tools like polygonal meshes, texture mapping, and dynamic lighting help with creating unparalleled realism, as seen in Pixar’s CGI films or photorealistic game environments. While a 3D workflows allows for asset reuse and free camera movement, it demands specialized software expertise and computational power, often complicating iterative design.
Crossing Between Dimensions
It’s very common when designing or illustrating to start with a 2D sketch, even if it will later be turned into a 3D model. This helps in understanding the dimensions of the object you’re trying to create, as well as its overall appearance.
From 2D - 3D
Generally, when moving from 2D to 3D, objects are drawn from different angles: front, back, top, bottom, and sides. This ensures a better representation of how the 2D concept will be translated into a 3D model. Most likely, the final 3D object will resemble the 2D version but won’t be exactly the same.
From 3D - 2D
When translating a 3D model into a 2D image, a very close depiction of the element can be made with incredible accuracy. However, the 2D image won’t be movable or allow for a change in perspective unless a new image is rendered from the same model at a different angle.